Adopting a multidimensional concept of uncertainty as its point of departure, this. Epistemic relativism is the position that knowledge is valid only relatively to a specific context, society, culture or individual. Here, we want to claim that there are at least two varieties of epistemic authority, one based on reliability and one on assuming nonepistemic authority. Epistemic authority and trust in shared decision making. A theory of trust, authority, and autonomy in belief. It thus entails not simply the addition of new knowledge, but the reorganization of. Epistemic authority and autonomy of the epistemic subject. Epistemic authority, testimony and the transmission of knowledge volume 4 issue 3 arnon keren skip to main content we use cookies to distinguish you from other users and to provide you with a better experience on our websites. Changing epistemic authority of religious expertise.
Zagzebski on epistemic authority zagzebskis project has two main components. Epistemic definition of epistemic by the free dictionary. Rather than simply paying respect to the decisions of another, one might allocate authority to another to make binding decisions. Deference may also refer to the allocation of authority. The psychology and epistemology of selfknowledge 167 take. Antireductionists take this feature as showing that the epistemology of testimony is dependent on social relations and the conferring of epistemic authority on speakers. For if joe cannot meet freds challenge to mary, mary loses her justification for asserting that bill and jane are divorcing see hinchman 2005. Xenophanes i think he says the epistemic authority is 1 god and the epistemic problem is bridging the gap between human opinion and divine knowledge. We claim that both are subject to linguistic negotiation. These two forms of authority are closely related to each other, and the deontic one must at least to some extent be based on. Focusing on epistemic deference, however, may cause one to overlook an equally important notion. Religious communication and epistemic authority of leaders.
Estlund uses the case of jury systems to show that original authority can be drawn from an epistemic proceduralist account grounded in normative consent. A read is counted each time someone views a publication summary such as the title, abstract, and list of authors, clicks on a figure, or views or downloads the fulltext. After the rupture the nonscientific past comes to be seen as so much superstition. The extent that a cognitive process can provide accurate knowledge. A typical example of epistemic authority is the relation of a teacher to his students. This allows them to accord individuals a degree of epistemic privilege with respect to their own inner goingson familiar accounts of epistemic terms seem to be divisible into those that employ only clearly naturalistic terms and those that do not let us begin with the first type of thrust, i. Epistemic petrification and the restoration of epistemic. Our framework is proposed as a heuristic rather than an etiological model, but a heuristic with, we hope, significant clinical implications. The epistemic significance of disagreement1 thomas kelly princeton university forthcoming in the inaugural volume of oxford studies in epistemology, edited by john hawthorne and tamar gendler. I had a vague idea of what a synecdoche was, and ignored until then that one could characterize ciceros writing in this way. One the focus of this paper is an account of the epistemically appropriate response to discovering that an epistemic authority holds certain beliefs. In this book linda trinkaus zagzebski gives an extended argument that the selfreflective person is committed to belief on authority.
Heraclitus im not sure what he says the epistemic authority is. Philosophy of or relating to knowledge or epistemology 2. This book gives an extended argument for epistemic authority from the implications of reflective selfconsciousness. Epistemic authority is compatible with autonomy, but epistemic selfreliance is incoherent. Given organ scarcity, transplantation programs state that patient promises of compliance cannot be taken at face value, excluding candidates who are deemed untrustworthy. Epistemology is the philosophical project of formulating such an explanation.
Epistemic authority and its critics linda zagzebski university of oklahoma the purpose of epistemic authority1 is to defend the rationality of belief on authority from the modern assumption that the ultimate authority over the self is the self. The chapter defends the existence of epistemic authority in the moral domain against objections from three directions. Just as with verdicts in jury trials, estlund argues, the authority and legitimacy of a political decision does not depend on the particular decision being good or correct. She argues that epistemic and emotional selftrust are rational and inescapable, that consistent selftrust commits us to trust in others, and that among those we are committed to trusting are some whom we ought to treat as epistemic authorities, modeled. In this way, the history of science is understood not so much a process of discovery as the overcoming of the obstacles to thought posed by knowledge itself. Religious epistemic authority depends on a system of communication relations that confers on clergy a special role and status in knowledge acquisition of the divine which in turn authorizes them to issue judgments, persuasions, and commands. Epistemic definition, of or relating to knowledge or the conditions for acquiring it. Epistemics definition of epistemics by the free dictionary. Humans massively depend on communication with others, but this leaves them open to the risk of. Origgi, gloria at highschool in italy many years ago i heard my teacher of latin say.
According to a recent account of epistemic authority proposed by linda zagzebski 2012, it is rational for laypersons to believe on authority when they conscientiously judge that the authority is more likely to form true beliefs and avoid false ones than they are in some domain. Fourth, because the ruling elites viewpoint is taken as the status quo, marginal groups must struggle and resist to uncover and express their standpoints. Leaders in organizations and elsewhere may have formal authorities but they mostly rely on the informal authority that they exercise on people to influence them. For example, suppose that progressive income tax rates armore just than a flat rate, even after considering effects on efficiency. Attachment is a much older instinct, in evolutionary terms, than the imperative to generate epistemic trust. Epistemic authority, preemptive reasons, and understanding.
The moment of rupture separating science from its nonscientific past. The book argues that epistemic and emotional selftrust are rational and inescapable, that consistent selftrust commits us to trust in others, and that among those we are committed to. But the epistemic value of the procedure the degree to which it can generally be accepted as tending. This chapter applies the arguments of previous chapters to the domain of moral belief. Intuitively this means that the other person or institution, or group is taken to be authoritative in what they say, at least with respect to a particular domain. It has occupied philosophers at least since the time of plato, and it continues to provide a central field of study in. In proposing that epistemic mistrust might underpin the p factor that underlies longterm impairment, we thus also consider that the relearning of epistemic trust may be at the heart of all effective psychotherapeutic interventions. I attach the label of epistemic deference to this notion. Epistemic authority, testimony and the transmission of. A philosophical explanation of firstperson authority. Epistemology epistemology concerns itself with ways of knowing and how we know. The authority exercised is a kind of legitimate power and people follow figures exercising it, because their positions demand so irrespective of the person holding the position. Nevertheless, i relied on my teachers intellectual authority to. We define this vulnerability as the impairment of epistemic trust.
The discussion about epistemic relativism is one of the most fundamental discussions in epistemology concerning our understanding of notions. Epistemic agency catherine z elgin harvard university, usa abstract virtue epistemologists hold that knowledge results from the display of epistemic virtues openmindedness, rigor, sensitivity to evidence, and the like. Looking back on it, it seems almost incredible that so many equally educated, equally. Our starting point is the remarkable and paradoxical combination of marked rigidity and. In one version, the authority is oneself were one to reflect extremely carefully. Firstperson authority is the thesis that the firstperson privileged introspective judgments that we make about the contents of our own occurrent thoughts are on a qualitatively better epistemic footing than the thirdperson ordinary perceptual judgments we make about the external world. On the contrary, deference to epistemic authority is a necessary part of human living in general and is especially indispensable in a modern, sciencebased society with an advanced division of cognitive labour fricker 1998. Epistemic definition of epistemic by merriamwebster. Epistemic authority hardcover linda trinkaus zagzebski. Epistemic meaning in the cambridge english dictionary. Introduction assume that for many choices faced by a political community, some alter natives are better than others by standards that are in some way objective. Epistemic democracy is the doctrine of the wisdom of the multitude. Igor gasparov 2017 epistemology and philosophy of science 53 3. What is wanted is a criterion for being an epistemic.
The role of mentalizing and epistemic trust in the. Analysing one particular stratigraphic controversy about the anthropocene, i argue that these answers afford flexibility to both expand the epistemic authority and protect the autonomy. Remarks on samaneh oladi ghadikolaei, womens religious authority in shi. Forest professionals claim and epistemic authority in the face of societal and climate change.
What is the epistemic authorityepistemic problem according to these philosophers. Epistemic definition is of or relating to knowledge or knowing. Pdf moral authority, epistemic authority, and gender. Epistemic trust as the key to effective psychotherapies. Epistemic authority is compatible with autonomy, but epistemic selfreliance is. Several recently defended views give a central role in the nature of epistemic justification to some kind of authority. According to the inferencebased model, a particular belief counts as epistemically justi. This chapter argues that they all have the sort of explanatory flaw that is famously.
916 146 238 1395 968 1092 160 607 1191 1136 1018 1427 746 667 1470 799 1082 169 755 390 599 792 742 620 200 3 1388 195 149 791 1356